This could be good

[Xray]

Who ever posts a song should provide two links that he/she gave two other songs proper feedback. And its gotta be recent feedback. I think all the rappers can agree with me on this one, since theres alot of people who just post songs and want feedback but don't feedback others. Same should go with the studio section, cause the producers deserve the same respect no doubt.

You with me on this one?

[Xray]

I agree, but the mods would never do it

We all should just agree on it, without making it a rule

true man, but lets see if the mods or administrators relate to us cause it would be much better if its a rule, cause there will always be rule breakers

[shady_soldier_]

how about you just don't give feedback to rule breakers then?

[,-,'-{Bar}-',-,]

this kills audio stages, the reason TR's is as active as it is is becuase we dont have these rules and we dont shun new comers.


seriously i been on other forums that have these rules and becuase everyone is forced to give feedback there is about 10% honest feedback, and when the people cant be bothered giving fake feedback they just hate coz its eisier, there is other system we could try get in place that dont force people to give feedback or force them to show 2 links.

the best way if your wanting the audio more active is give feeback to new guys and hope that they get a warm enough welcome to be confident enough to post more songs, like mesayah probly a bad example because he has skills but im pretty sure he'll stick around coz no one has been an asshole with him and even when giving negatives they are doin it contructively.

when new people post and the first 3 replies are "give feedback then ill give you feed" is all well and good but its annoying when your a new member becuase you have not been shown anything that you will be getting decent feedback or fake feedback or just plain hate.

best thing to do is when new people post give contrsuctive criticism, even if they suck dont be an asshole about it, im not saying suck up there ass just dont go like "you suck stop rapping you have no flow" just encourage them to keep it up and give them tips on how to improve, then at the bottom of the feedback just put a simple "and hey man try give feedback to other people and youll get more feedback" and new members will stick around

[Xray]

well fake feedback or real feedback some people on this forum hardly even give proper feedback when they do feed songs. so if you think people with 10 posts should post songs and not feed back others but others feed back there work is fair than life's a bitch for real!

[,-,'-{Bar}-',-,]

well fake feedback or real feedback some people on this forum hardly even give proper feedback when they do feed songs. so if you think people with 10 posts should post songs and not feed back others but others feed back there work is fair than life's a bitch for real!

im not saying its fair im saying its the best option to increase activity, coz trust me if we brought in the "need to post 2 links of feed you have given" system the audio stage will die and become non-existent ive seen it happen on around 3 forums and ive joined about 5 thats had the system and no one in it has any chemistery at all its like giving feebdack is a chore instead of a way to help each other and its not nice, i much prefer the way it is on TR, also post count shouldnt come in to it coz when someone new joins they could have 3 posts (2 giving feedback and 1 posting there own track) so you cant judge them like that.

and if people do post there own stuff and not ever give feedback even when you give them feedback just ignore them, the first couple of times though id suggest just letting it slide and let them get familiar with the people on the forum a bit and see that we are nice guys and not haters then theyll start giving feed and if they dont, then ignore them.

[Xray]

well fake feedback or real feedback some people on this forum hardly even give proper feedback when they do feed songs. so if you think people with 10 posts should post songs and not feed back others but others feed back there work is fair than life's a bitch for real!

im not saying its fair im saying its the best option to increase activity, coz trust me if we brought in the "need to post 2 links of feed you have given" system the audio stage will die and become non-existent ive seen it happen on around 3 forums and ive joined about 5 thats had the system and no one in it has any chemistery at all its like giving feebdack is a chore instead of a way to help each other and its not nice, i much prefer the way it is on TR, also post count shouldnt come in to it coz when someone new joins they could have 3 posts (2 giving feedback and 1 posting there own track) so you cant judge them like that.

and if people do post there own stuff and not ever give feedback even when you give them feedback just ignore them, the first couple of times though id suggest just letting it slide and let them get familiar with the people on the forum a bit and see that we are nice guys and not haters then theyll start giving feed and if they dont, then ignore them.

shit you've made a strong point and i agree 100%

[EM4EVER]

yeah