by EminemBase » Aug 26th, '12, 23:40
Well yeah, I agree that it doesn't by definition mean you don't care about somebody to do it; and you're right that logically, if they didn't find out, it wouldn't emotionally damage them. As they wouldn't know.
But then I think that's where the self-monitoring of consciousness and conscience come in to play and you just have to ask yourself if you genuinely feel okay in yourself in doing it. If the answer to you is yes, and it creates no ill feelings or feelings of wrongful doing on your part, go ahead.
I think most people do feel something wrong in doing it (but I'm not saying you should) which is why, when they do 'slip-up' - they often tell their partner. As they feel they need to 'unload' the burden of guilt.
If you don't see any problems in it then, do what feels right to you, or which you can soundly justify to yourself. I'm wondering though, do you truly feel okay with it; as, you created this thread to get other people's perspectives on it, in a sense indicating that there's some kind of internal grapple happening on the issue; or you at least pay some mind to the idea that it feels wrong, else you wouldn't be asking?
I could be wrong, and you might genuinely feel dumfounded about it being wrong and want to get input from others on why they think it is, as it's a popular notion that it is...
Personally: I don't feel it's right to do it deceptively. As when it boils down to it, it is deception. So whilst you're right that the person wouldn't literally get hurt by the fact, if they did not know the fact - I would still know the fact, I would know I had cheated, and I would have had to lie or at some point not reveal the fact; which in itself makes me feel consciously dishonest. And I like being honest.
I think a better justification would be if you had a partner who agreed to have an 'open relationship' with you in which they knew and were fine with you sleeping with other people. That way, you wold still get to sleep with other people, but you wouldn't have to have a potential burden of deception on your conscience, and this would be totally ethically sound, as both parties are aware and fine with it. Then of course, it wouldn't be 'cheating', so in essence, I would have to conclude that I can't personally justify it, as it feels dishonest.