I know Crash appreciates not using the scoring, but I did at the bottom anyway, to back up my un-scored judging.
Crash wins.Crash opened his verse with a "meme" that's been going around, and it actually made me laugh. Not only that, he brought it back with the "I Cunt" line, linking to the same fucking site he made fun of Superman for going to. I thought it was a nice continuation of the punch. Plus the "Call of Duty package / all exclusive pamphlet" rhyme made me wet haha. Crash also had some funny lines in there, such as the second base and the final line.
Superman had a nice flow as well, but I felt Crash went the extra distance writing to a beat. Plus Superman dissed Crash on his flow being bad, but... Crash has a dope flow. Lol. Superman, I've read your pieces in CW, man, and the rhyming here is a step down from your usual pieces.
So yeah, I think Crash won this with his funny punches, rhyming and complexity with coming up with the punches. Superman's verse just felt... generic, I guess. Sure, you mentioned he's from New Zealand but didn't really do anything with it.
But for the sake of score judging, here's my picks anyhow.
(3) Punchlines - CB
(3) Personals - CB
(2) Multies - CB
(1) Flow - CB
(1) Structure - Superman
(1) Vocab/Complex - CB
CrashBand - 10
Superman - 1